forums


Please Login to your GreenMetropolis.com Account to Post and Reply in the Forum
RSS Feed
Posts in Topic : All Forums | Historical | Cathars, Templars et al
Started 06/05/2009 13:24 by Bouquiniste. Topic has 16 reply(s).

Bouquiniste

Bouquiniste

Stars 4.62 Stars

Ratings120

Joined02/02/2005

Posts11

Cathars, Templars et al
#1 Posted 06/05/2009 13:24

Afternoon all.

Does anyone have any recommendations on well-researched but readable books on the Cathars/Knights Templar/Magdalene connections to Languedoc? Similar vein: which is the best book on the unmasking of the Priory of Sion (sic) scam from the 50s?

PLEASE no-one mention Dan Brown or I may chew my arm off. And that would make an awful mess.


Thanks!!

 

Sunshine Girl

Sunshine Girl

Stars 4.94 Stars

Ratings65

Joined27/02/2007

Posts251

Re:Cathars, Templars et al
#2 Posted 06/05/2009 14:26

I have seen a book called The Last Templar by Raymond Khoury might be what you're looking for.

 

Bouquiniste

Bouquiniste

Stars 4.62 Stars

Ratings120

Joined02/02/2005

Posts11

Re:Cathars, Templars et al
#3 Posted 06/05/2009 16:01

Thanks Sunshine; unfortunately that's a prime example of exactly the sort of book I'm NOT looking for. Not looking for DVC-type fiction, I'm after the historian/expert stuff.

Really good of you to try to help, though!

 

nefertaya

nefertaya

Stars 5.00 Stars

Ratings1

Joined08/05/2009

Posts3

Re:Cathars, Templars et al
#4 Posted 08/05/2009 16:12

Not sure if these are any good, I've read these and am selling them on to get some more Templar style books although tbh I think people have listed them cheaper than mine when I last looked lol.

Lynn Picknett & Clive Prince - The Templar Revelation
I found it very interesting in a non DVC way.

Laurence Gardner - The Magdalene Legacy
Also very interesting.

 

Bouquiniste

Bouquiniste

Stars 4.62 Stars

Ratings120

Joined02/02/2005

Posts11

Re:Cathars, Templars et al
#5 Posted 09/05/2009 21:32

Thanks, nefertaya.

 

AWheatley

AWheatley

Stars 4.33 Stars

Ratings3

Joined28/12/2008

Posts1

Re:Cathars, Templars et al
#6 Posted 20/05/2009 23:02

These don't really have the Templar connection but are the best books I've read about the Cathars...

Zoe Oldenbourg - Massacre at Montsegur or
Stephen O'Shea - The Perfect Heresy
Have read both and they give historical background to the Cathars and aren't too heavy going to read.

Rene Weis - The Yellow Cross - A good if somewhat dense book telling the story of the last Cathars from the Inquisitional Records in the Vatican.

Hope this helps...

 

79762

79762

Stars 4.64 Stars

Ratings14

Joined06/03/2007

Posts3

Re:Cathars, Templars et al
#7 Posted 23/05/2009 08:41

Ihave a book in my collection The Knights Templar by Sean Martin.
He's a renowned historian and 'expert' on the subject and was recently on TV in a documentary.
There ar 3 copies available at GreenM.

 

KirstyGirl

KirstyGirl

Stars 4.84 Stars

Ratings172

Joined10/08/2005

Posts124

Re:Cathars, Templars et al
#8 Posted 13/07/2009 18:56
Montaillou

Montaillou
Emmanuel Le Roy Ladurie

The classic book on the subject of the Cathars is "Montaillou". I read it in the seventies and loved it.

Edited: Spelling (13/07/2009 18:57)  

AGOT1878

AGOT1878

Stars 5.00 Stars

Ratings8

Joined13/07/2009

Posts7

Re:Cathars, Templars et al
#9 Posted 13/07/2009 19:23

I read a book 3 years back called the Tomb of God. It dealt more with the secrets hidden within renaissance paintings and a bit about the Templars. Not a light read by any stretch, but very interesting IMO.
Here is a link to Amazon for a review.

http:www.amazon.com/Tomb-God-Solution-000-Year-Old-Mystery/dp/0316042757

 

geohast

geohast

Stars 5.00 Stars

Ratings1

Joined01/08/2009

Posts1

Re:Cathars, Templars et al
#10 Posted 01/08/2009 18:33

I agree with Kirsty Girl - Montaillou is the definitive history of the Cathars
For a different take on the topic (and well researched historically) you might look at Kate Mosse's novel "Labyrinth"

 

foreigntex

foreigntex

Stars 5.00 Stars

Ratings2

Joined24/04/2008

Posts21

Re:Cathars, Templars et al
#11 Posted 02/08/2009 18:13

I have just returned from Canal du Midi, Carcassonne en pays Cathare. Adjacent to the Lock Le Somail, was the largest second hand book shop I have seen in France. Very organised and well staffed and well turned out. I assume the tourist bureaux of which there are many would supply their website as they were certainly on line. Ask Google to recommend titles, then ask this emporium for advice.They even had an outside for FREE department and an honesty section, self service when closed. You may know all this intimately or even own the book shop, for all I know

 

foreigntex

foreigntex

Stars 5.00 Stars

Ratings2

Joined24/04/2008

Posts21

Re:Cathars, Templars et al
#12 Posted 25/08/2009 10:07
Yellow Cross

Yellow Cross
Rene J.A. Weis

There is a copy of Yellow Cross in stock

 

marie

marie

Stars 5.00 Stars

Ratings819

Joined06/07/2004

Posts721

Re:Cathars, Templars et al
#13 Posted 25/05/2010 22:17

Just another (string of asterisks)who asks and never returns This site wont even let me represent naughties

Edited: Spelling (25/05/2010 22:17)  

Bouquiniste

Bouquiniste

Stars 4.62 Stars

Ratings120

Joined02/02/2005

Posts11

Re:Cathars, Templars et al
#14 Posted 18/06/2010 13:22

Thank you for your helpful post, marie. It is true that after returning, and thanking, the original posters I was inordinately busy for both work and personal reasons and did not have time to read (any) forums. I admit to having forgotten that I had posted this until you so kindly bumped it to the front page.

To all whom I haven't yet thanked, thanks! I did turn up several books last year, but Montaillou and foreigntex's ideas will be certainly be followed up. Many apologies for not replying before.

 

marie

marie

Stars 5.00 Stars

Ratings819

Joined06/07/2004

Posts721

Re:Cathars, Templars et al
#15 Posted 22/06/2010 21:45

Sorry, I was all snarled up about those who ask questions when very new and never return. I did not think you were in that category. I had only recently visited Carcassonne for the first time and was quite overwhelmed. I could not understand why every nook and cranny had not been the backdrop for some T.V.series or film. Conceitedly, I thought ' It was too incredible to be undiscovered by me'.
Have you heard the BBC Radio 4 Programme on The Bouquinistes by The Seine today? I bet it was your prog!

Edited: omission (22/06/2010 21:56)  

Bouquiniste

Bouquiniste

Stars 4.62 Stars

Ratings120

Joined02/02/2005

Posts11

Re:Cathars, Templars et al
#16 Posted 28/06/2010 11:15

No I didn't hear it - wish I had! Thanks for the tip though, will hunt to see if it's still available as a podcast.

 

10137

10137

Stars 4.23 Stars

Ratings505

Joined02/07/2004

Posts10

Re:Cathars, Templars et al
#17 Posted 12/07/2010 18:09

Hello

For the Knights Templar try Supremely Abominable Crimes - The Trial of the Knight Templar by Edward Burman, on sale, by me, from this site. It's accessible academic history mainly drawn from inquisitorial records. Nice looking large format paperback - not sure why the cover art isn't in the database. Proper history with facts, dates and evidence: Dan Brown would not approve. I think the scholarly consensus would be that the Cathars and Templars didn't have much in common other than both groups variously contriving to get themselves onto the wrong side of both the Inquisition and the nascent French state. If you're interested in other sensible histories drawn from inquisitorial records (in Italy) have a look at items by Carlo Ginsberg including The Cheese and the Worms and The Night Battles. (I'm not selling my copies of these). Who needs esoteric cobblers with Tom Hanks in? This sort of thing is much more interesting.

Edited: typos (12/07/2010 18:13)